I've started work at a company doing video work and trying to create videos that are consistent with their previous videos. However, the more I look at the previous videos, the less I'm sure about one of the techniques, so want some help. It was an external video company that created them so it's possible they used some fancy techniques.

In the image below, it shows a toolbox: in the video it zooms in on this and it's definitely a video because the perspective changes as it zooms in. What i'm not sure about is how they clipped the toolbox out so neatly? My colleagues that worked with the company previously said they didn't use green screen, although they used a white backdrop at times.

The second image is another example, someone picking a worktop off a bench, but background is perfectly keyed out. I can get it this perfect with a green screen but I don't have any luck in doing it any other way - how would they have cut the products out so well?

(I can provide links to the videos if it's helpful - let me know)

TuffBank vid clipped out

enter image description here


Looking at your first example, I woul guess green screen, and not a particularly good one. It looks like they really need to increase the spill suppression, judging by the green spill evident on the feet of the bin.

An alternative approach is to shoot in a studio with an infinite white cyc, for example something like this one (randomly selected from a duckduckgo search, not necessarily endorsed). When lit correctly it will look like the second example, though that too could totally have been done with greenscreen—the forearms look a lot like there's spill that's been corrected.

enter image description here

The reason for shooting against green, rather than shooting against white or black is when you want to do background replacement. If you know that the background is going to just be white, then shooting against white is the way to go. But if you want to replace the background and you use white (or black) then any highlights (or shadows) are going to become transparent. It's much easier to keep green out of your foreground than stopping it having any highlights or shadows.

Another approach is to use rotoscoping. This is where masks are drawn around the foreground to cut it out from the background. While software like After Effects includes tools to automate this task somewhat, it is still a very time and labour-intensive process, and generally the results are inferior to other techniques. I would use rotoscoping only as a last resort, and I don't think I'm alone here.


Most likely it was a graphic done in Photoshop where you can easily cut out the photo. Then it was saved as a tiff, png or jpeg. Your editing program would then be able to import that, and allow you to place it into your timeline. If it is shot on video, the quality would not bee as good as shown. A png or tiff would allow you to save it out of Photoshop without any background and have what is called an Alpha Channel embedded into the photo. If you can't figure out how to do that, in Photoshop you could use a new layer below the photo and fill it with green and then save that out as a png. You then import that into your editing program, and drop it onto the timeline. then you can use the 'green screen command on that layer which should drop out the green and show through whatever background you want on it. Graphics will always come out nicer if imported into your editing program than shooting it direct onto video.

  • 1
    In my question, I stated that it was a video, not a graphic as the perspective changes as the video zooms in. Thanks for taking the time to post an answer though. – 5Diraptor Jun 29 '18 at 14:20

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.