Take the 2-minute tour ×
Video Production Stack Exchange is a question and answer site for engineers, producers, editors, and enthusiasts spanning the fields of video, and media creation. It's 100% free, no registration required.

I work in a developmental psychology lab where it would be useful to have audio / video documentation of notable behavior and speech patterns. Sessions with subjects last for several hours, and during this time, most of my attention is devoted to the proper administration of tests. It would be nice to have something as simple as a button press that inserts some type of marker / flag / bookmark / chapter division into the video footage whenever I observe noteworthy behavior I'll want to review later on. During review, I envision being able to use the marker system to jump straight to these moments of interest.

The chief issue I'm trying to avoid here is wasting a bunch of time searching through hours of tape just to collect a few minutes (or even seconds) of worthwhile footage.

I realize that a low-tech workaround would be to just synchronize a stopwatch to the start of the tape, and just glance at this / jot down times whenever anything interesting happens. However, this would still be a somewhat cumbersome undertaking, as I also use a stopwatch during the administration of several tests.

Is anybody familiar with any specific camcorders that could handle this sort of thing? Perhaps a model that lets you insert "chapter breaks" while recording? Any input is appreciated - I feel I may be missing some other obvious ideas here.

P.S. Ideally, my "button" would actually be a foot-pedal beneath the testing table, which would, in some way, communicate with the camcorder - but I'd be plenty satisfied if I could accomplish this via some button operation on the camcorder itself.

share|improve this question

3 Answers 3

If the camcorder records stereo sound and you are only interested in mono recordings, the foot switch could trigger an oscillator that injected a short tone on the left channel and the inverted tone on the right channel.

During regular playback where you might be mixing left and right audio to one mono audio signal, the tone will be unheard because of electrical cancellation of the signals. However, if you had a small electronic circuit that looked for the presence of the tone on (say) the right channel then it would find it.

A better version would use a balanced differential amplifier to look at both left and right together - pure mono sounds (i.e. the sounds you collected in your recording) would be totally cancelled by the differential mixing in the amplifier whereas the "tone" you injected would be plainly and unambiguously heard reminding you to play back the regular recording at this point.

share|improve this answer
    
this is indeed a crafty solution. it seems as though it would still be somewhat of an undertaking to scan through all of the footage in search of the marker tones... –  jptacek Sep 25 '13 at 20:23
    
@jptacek I'm guessing here but if the "playback system" has a remote pause feature, something could be interfaced that allowed you to wander off and make a cup of tea and in the meanwhile if the "tone detector" heard the tone it could pause the playback. Another way would be let the playback commence from the beginning and record the "secret" audio onto a wave file on a PC - then examine the wave file afterwards to see where the events occur in time - something like audacity or wavelab would do this. No need to be present throughout. Maybe audio works on fast forward too? –  Andy aka Sep 25 '13 at 20:32

This was a feature on some Mini DV camcorders back in the day. I know the Canon GL2 supported it, but as I recall I think it also required a MiniDV tape with a circuit in it that cost extra and I'm not sure if you can still get them anymore. Having to deal with capturing tapes is also a bit of a pain.

If you don't mind a momentary break in the footage, you can timecode your footage based on the actual time in some DSLRs and then can take a photo (which interrupts the recording for a second) and the meta data will also have the time of the photo. It's then just a matter of looking for the timestamps of the photos within the video to find the behavior.

share|improve this answer

I use Cut Notes (warning, paywall) application for iPad.

Long story short,

  1. Define your own "events", grouped by category Events
  2. During recording or playback, click the buttons, and they are recorded along with the timeline;
  3. Export the data into your favorite post-mastering application or just into a plain text: Timeline
  4. Since the projects are editable, it's easy to take your initial notes while recording and improve them during further previews.

See Cut Notes Overview video on Youtube.

I'm pretty sure there are also a plenty of free apps available as well as apps for other platforms like Android.

share|improve this answer

Your Answer

 
discard

By posting your answer, you agree to the privacy policy and terms of service.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.